
Generally an offer of a free book raises my suspicions and I don't take up the offer because I have to divulge my name and address (call me paranoid). However, this free book was advertised on the Biblegateway website which is quite a respectable site and the title caught my attention so I ordered the free book.
I was quite surprised by the book. Basically, K.P Yohannan, the founder of the mission organisation Gospel for Asia asserts that western churches should stop sending western missionaries to Asia but instead use that money to support native missionaries. Native missionaries cost a fraction of the money required to support a Western missionary and native missionaries are much more effective. He sights a couple of exceptions. Perhaps western missionaries are needed in countries like Afghanistan and a few countries like that where there are very few Christians and no native missionaries. The rest, we should be supporting native missionaries.
The other significant thrust of the book is that western churches are prejudiced in terms of there giving. They give money to their own missionaries without much accountability for how effective they are but when it comes to giving money to native missionary organisation, they demand accountability and request someone from the organisation to sit on the governing committee in the local country.
He conceded that western missionary were necessary in the past in places like China to bring the gospel to that country. But now he argues that most western missionaries are either just doing social work rather than preaching the gospel or they are just ineffective.
It is true that native missionaries cost much less and usually are much more effective in evangelising their own people. And yes, some missionary are probably not very effective on the mission field and really should be back in their home country.
However, I doubt that if western church stopped sending western missionaries and just gave money to native missionaries, that we would see the great advance in the cause of world missions which K.P seems to suggest. Some might think that because they have given money to support native missionaries and prayed for them that they've done their bit for world mission.
K.P raises some important issues which we need to reflect upon. Gospel for Asia seem to be doing an amazing work. But I don't think the answer is as clear cut as K.P implies and he focuses too much on his experiences of ineffective western missionaries but neglects those who are being used tremendously by God. The book is free from
here.